Rate of Return (RoR) and Return on Investment
(RoI) of Indonesia and India
Rika
Yohana Sari1, Batina Yulia Utami2, Hadianto3,
Yahya4
Universitas
Negeri Padang, Indonesia
Email: rikayohana46@gmail.com1*,
batinatulisutami@gmail.com2,
hadiyanto@fip.unp.ac.id3,
yahya_tambunan@yahoo.com4
Abstract
In
the era of globalization and economic liberalization, cross-border investment
has become the main strategy for developing countries to increase their
economic growth and global competitiveness. This research aims to explore and
compare RoR and RoI in Indonesia and India and identify key factors that
influence the differences in RoR and RoI between the two countries. This
research method uses literature study and conceptual analysis to collect and
analyze data from various sources. The research results show that the
comparison of RoR and RoI between Indonesia and India involves various factors
such as macroeconomic conditions, infrastructure, political stability,
investment regulations, labor market, market, and industry, as well as
innovation and technology. The two countries show significant differences and
similarities in these factors, which influence investment returns. Indonesia
has relatively good political stability and a developed capital market, while
India stands out in the technology sector and economic reform. However,
challenges such as complex regulations, inadequate infrastructure, and
fluctuations in currency exchange rates remain obstacles to achieving optimal
ROI for investors.
Keywords:
economy, investment, Indonesia, India
Introduction
In the era of
globalization and economic liberalization, cross-border investment has become a
key strategy for many developing countries to boost their economic growth and
global competitiveness
In the context of globalization and economic
liberalization, countries are increasingly opening themselves up to domestic
and foreign investment, as is the case with Indonesia and India. Indonesia and
India, as two developing countries with rapid economic growth, offer a variety
of investment opportunities. These two countries have unique economic,
political, and social dynamics, which affect the rate of return on investment.
To understand the effectiveness of these investments, the two main indicators
that are often used are Rate of Return (RoR) and Return on Investment (RoI).
These two indicators provide an overview of the profitability and efficiency of
investments made in a country
Rate of Return (RoR) and Return on Investment
(RoI) are the two main indicators used to measure returns on investments. RoR
measures the percentage of profit or loss of an investment relative to the
initial cost of the investment. In contrast, RoI measures the efficiency of an
investment by comparing the profit obtained with the cost of the investment).
These two metrics provide different but complementary views of investment
performance, which is crucial for investors to make informed and strategic
investment decisions. Although the two are often used interchangeably, a clear
understanding of the differences and their applications is essential for
investors to better assess their investments' risks and returns
Comparative analysis between Indonesia and
India in the context of RoR and RoI is important to understand how the
investment environment in each country can influence investment decisions and
economic growth strategies. This study aims to explore and compare RoR and RoI
in Indonesia and India. By analyzing data from both countries, the study hopes
to provide insights into how differences in the economic and policy environment
can affect investment returns. In addition, the study also sought to identify
the key factors that contribute to the differences in RoR and RoI between the
two countries.
The study on "Rate of Return (RoR) and
Return on Investment (RoI) of Indonesia and India" seeks to analyze and
compare investment performance in two developing countries with dynamic
economic characteristics. This study differs from previous studies that focused
on the influence of financial performance on RoR in a more specific context.
For example, the research "The Influence of Financial Performance on Rate
of Return (Empirical Study on Mining Companies Listed on the IDX in 2014-2018)"
examines the relationship between financial performance and RoR, specifically
in the mining sector in Indonesia. Likewise, the study "The Effect of
Financial Performance on Rate of Return (RoR) in Award-Winning Companies in
2013-2015" examined companies that won awards over a certain period
Meanwhile, the research "Measurement of
Financial Performance Based on ROI (Return on Investment) with the DuPont
System Approach at PT. Tropica Cocoprima" uses a specific analysis method
on a single company in Indonesia, which deepens the RoI analysis but does not
provide a cross-country comparison. This study examines the RoR and the RoI and
conducts cross-country comparisons, namely Indonesia and India, to provide a
broader picture of the factors affecting investment performance in the two
countries. This approach is expected to provide a more comprehensive insight
into both countries' diverse and dynamic investment environments
Previous research underpins the significance
of this study, highlighting the pivotal role of cross-border investment in
boosting economic growth and competitiveness in developing nations
The urgency of this research is multifaceted.
In the era of globalization and economic liberalization, countries like
Indonesia and India are increasingly welcoming both domestic and foreign
investments, making it crucial to understand their investment climates and
returns. The proven reciprocal relationship between economic growth and
investment further underscores the need for such analysis, as it can guide
sustainable economic strategies. Investors require comprehensive, comparative
data on investment returns to make informed decisions, and this study provides
a necessary comparative analysis of two significant emerging markets. For
policymakers, insights from this research can inform policies to enhance the
investment climate and attract more investments. As both countries seek to
diversify their economies, understanding the sectors offering the best returns
on investment can help optimize economic development strategies. This research
addresses a gap in existing literature, which often focuses on single-country
analyses or sector-specific studies, by offering a holistic view of the
investment environments in Indonesia and India. Consequently, this study is
significant for its contributions to academic literature and practical insights
for investors and policymakers aiming to optimize investment strategies and
foster economic growth in these countries.
Overall, this study not only aims to provide
a comparative overview of Rate Of Return (ROR) and Return On Investment (ROI)
in Indonesia and India, but also to provide a deeper understanding of the
factors that affect the Rate Of Return (ROR) and Return On Investment (ROI) in
Indonesia and India. As such, this research is expected to make an important
contribution to the investment and economic literature, as well as to
policymakers and market participants involved in investment in the two
countries.
Research Methods
The
research method utilized in this study is a literature review, where the author
gathers information from various sources, including books, journals, articles,
and other documents. Rather than collecting data directly or communicating with
respondents, the authors analyze existing information from these written
sources. The approach is conceptual, emphasizing ideas and theories. The
authors read notes, and organize research materials for an in-depth analysis,
leveraging literature sources.
Data sources for this research encompass
academic journals that discuss Rate of Return (RoR), Return on Investment
(RoI), and the investment climates of Indonesia and India; authoritative books
on development economics, globalization, economic liberalization, and
investment strategies; reports from international organizations such as the
World Bank, International Monetary Fund (IMF), and United Nations Conference on
Trade and Development (UNCTAD) that provide statistical data and analysis on
investment trends and economic growth in developing countries; government
publications from Indonesia and India related to economic policies, investment
regulations, and economic performance indicators; and relevant articles from
reputable business and economic news sources offering current insights and data
on the investment environments in Indonesia and India.
The data analysis technique involves several steps:
gathering relevant literature from identified sources, organizing the
literature into categories based on themes such as economic growth, RoR, RoI,
investment policies, and comparative studies between Indonesia and India, and
performing a detailed content analysis to extract key concepts, theories, and
data points. A comparative analysis is then conducted to identify similarities,
differences, and trends in the investment environments and performance metrics
of the two countries. Finally, the analyzed data is synthesized and interpreted
to develop a comprehensive understanding of the factors affecting RoR and RoI
in both countries, providing insights for investors and policymakers. By
employing these methods, the study aims to offer a thorough comparative
analysis of investment performance in Indonesia and India, contributing
valuable knowledge to the fields of economic development and international
investment.
Results
and Discussion
Comparison of Return on Investment (ROI) and
rate of Return (RoR) in Indonesia and India
According
to Srivastava et al.
1.
Economic
Conditions
A comparison of investment
returns from the perspective of economic conditions reveals significant
differences in economic structure, sector composition, and macroeconomic
stability, including between Indonesia and India. India, as the world's
sixth-largest economy with dynamic economic growth, has a thriving service
sector, especially in the fields of information technology, financial services,
and outsourcing. The growth of these sectors has attracted significant foreign
direct investment and relatively provides a high rate of return for investors.
On the other hand, Indonesia has a more diverse economic structure, with the
dominant agricultural, manufacturing, and extractive sectors. Although
Indonesia has shown strong economic growth in recent years, challenges such as
inadequate infrastructure, complex bureaucracy, and fluctuations in commodity
prices can affect the rate of return on investment in several sectors. Source:
World Bank, Government Investment Centre of India
2.
Regulations
and Policies
In terms of investment
regulations and policies, Indonesia and India have striking differences that
can affect the rate of return on investment in both countries. In Indonesia,
although there have been efforts to improve the investment climate through
legislative reforms and pro-investor policies, there are still some obstacles
such as complex bureaucracy, convoluted regulations, and legal uncertainty,
that can reduce investment attractiveness. In addition, corruption and
compliance with the law are major concerns for foreign investors. On the other
hand, India has undergone a number of significant economic reforms in recent
years, including efforts to improve the investment climate by simplifying
regulations and procedures, providing fiscal incentives, and increasing
transparency. Nonetheless, frequent policy changes and political uncertainty
can be challenging for investors. In 2020, India also launched "One Nation
One Market" for the agricultural sector, opening the door for greater
investment in the sector
Political Stability
The comparison of investment
returns between Indonesia and India in terms of political stability shows a
significant difference between the two countries. Indonesia has enjoyed a
relatively stable period since the Reformasi in 1998. Despite the occasional
political turmoil, strong democratic governments and peaceful transitions of
power have provided reassurance to investors. According to a report from Ernst
& Young, the investment climate in Indonesia has improved thanks to the
government's efforts to carry out structural reforms, improve infrastructure,
and promote foreign investment. On the other hand, India has a more dynamic
political history with frequent changes in government and regional political
instability. Despite progress in economic reforms, such as the "Make in
India" program designed to encourage investment, frequent policy changes
and political uncertainty have deterred investors. According to a McKinsey
report political uncertainty in India has slowed down investment growth,
especially in the infrastructure sector
3.
Pass
Modal
The comparison of the rate of
return on investment from the capital market between Indonesia and India shows
some relevant differences and similarities. According to data from Bloomberg,
over the past few years, the Indian capital market has shown quite strong
performance with promising rates of return for investors. This is largely
driven by stable economic growth, pro-investment reform policies, and the
growth of prominent industrial sectors such as IT, pharmaceuticals, and
financial services. On the other hand, Indonesia's capital market also showed
positive growth despite higher volatility. Factors such as relatively good
political stability and massive infrastructure projects have been key drivers
for Indonesia's capital market growth. However, the rate of return on
investment in Indonesia tends to be influenced by internal factors such as
domestic economic and political policies and currency volatility that can
affect overall investment performance. Nonetheless, both capital markets offer
attractive investment opportunities with diverse potential returns, depending
on the risk profile and investor preferences.
4.
Inflation
The comparison of Return on
Investment (ROI) between Indonesia and India from an inflation perspective
shows a difference in the impact of inflation on investment value. Although
both countries face significant inflation challenges, there are variations in
rates and their impact on ROI. India, for example, has experienced a relatively
high inflation rate in recent years, with the inflation rate reaching around
5-6% in 2022. This high inflation rate can reduce the real value of the return
on investment, effectively reducing ROI. On the other hand, Indonesia has
managed to control inflation in recent years, with the inflation rate reaching
around 3% in 2023
5.
Currency
Risk
A comparison between the rate of return on
investment in Indonesia and India in terms of currency risk can provide an
interesting picture. Indonesia has a rupiah (IDR) currency, which tends to be
more susceptible to market fluctuations compared to the Indian currency, the
rupee (INR). Since India has larger foreign exchange reserves and a relatively
more stable economy, the rupee exchange rate tends to be more managed. On the
other hand, the Indonesian rupiah often experiences pressure, especially when
there is global uncertainty or internal factors such as the current account
deficit. In the context of investment, this currency risk can affect the rate
of return on investment for foreign investors investing in both countries. For
example, if a foreign investor invests in the Indonesian and Indian stock
markets, fluctuations in the rupiah exchange rate against the US dollar can
affect his overall return on investment. This suggests that in terms of
currency risk, investors may be more likely to view India as a slightly more
stable option than Indonesia. However, this comparison can also vary depending
on other factors, such as the economic, political, and monetary policy
conditions of each country.
Factors Affecting Rate Of Return (ROR) and Return On Investment (ROI) in
Indonesia and India
1.
Macroeconomic Conditions
Macroeconomic conditions affect the Rate of Return
(RoR) and Return on Investment (ROI) in Indonesia and India through various
indicators such as economic growth, inflation, and monetary policy. Stable
economic growth and a controlled inflation rate can boost investor confidence
and encourage investment growth, increasing RoR and ROI. In addition, the
monetary policy implemented by central banks also has effects, such as interest
rates and market liquidity, which can affect the cost of capital and investment
returns. Therefore, a deep understanding of each country's relevant
macroeconomic and policy conditions is important to measure and predict RoR and
ROI
2.
Infrastructure
Good infrastructure is crucial in influencing the
Rate of Return (RoR) and Return on Investment (ROI) in Indonesia and India.
Investments in robust infrastructure, including transportation,
telecommunications, and energy, can improve a company's operational efficiency,
reduce logistics costs, and expand market access, all of which can improve RoR.
In Indonesia, infrastructure development programs such as toll road
construction and port development have recently been implemented to improve
connectivity and logistics efficiency. Meanwhile, in India, investment in road
infrastructure, rail, and energy projects has become a key focus to support
economic growth and create investment opportunities
3.
Political Stability
Political stability is a very important factor in
influencing the Rate of Return (RoR) and Return on Investment (ROI) in
Indonesia and India. Good political stability creates a conducive investment
environment by reducing the risk of uncertainty and market volatility, which in
turn increases investor confidence. In Indonesia, political stability has
helped create a safer business climate, which attracts more foreign and
domestic investment, as noted by the World Bank in a report
4.
Investment Regulation
Investment regulation plays an important role in
influencing the Rate of Return (RoR) and Return on Investment (ROI) in
Indonesia and India, with each country having a different policy approach that
can affect investment attractiveness. In India, the government has carried out
various reforms to improve the investment climate, including loosening
restrictions on foreign ownership in several sectors and improving the ease of
doing business through initiatives such as "Make in India" and
liberalization of Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) policies
5.
Labor Market Conditions
Labor market conditions greatly affect the Rate of
Return (RoR) and Return on Investment (ROI) in Indonesia and India because
skills, availability, and labor costs have a direct impact on operational
efficiency and business productivity. In Indonesia, unemployment and an
increasingly skilled workforce are helping to boost productivity, although
challenges related to labor costs and labor regulations remain. Despite having
a large and young workforce in India, key challenges include inadequate
education and training and high unemployment rates among youth, which can
affect productivity and operational costs
6.
Markets and Industries
Market and industry factors greatly affect the Rate
of Return (RoR) and Return on Investment (ROI) in Indonesia and India. Both
countries have large and diverse markets with significant growth potential in
various sectors. In India, the information technology, pharmaceutical, and
outsourcing services sectors have shown a high RoR thanks to strong global
demand and a competitive advantage in low labor costs
7.
Innovation and Technology
Innovation and technology are important factors that
affect the Rate of Return (RoR) and Return on Investment (ROI) in Indonesia and
India. Both countries are in the process of significant digital transformation,
which can improve operational efficiency and open up new opportunities for
investors. In Indonesia, the adoption of digital technologies in sectors such
as fintech, e-commerce, and agritech has increased productivity and
competitiveness. Meanwhile, India, with its rapid advancement in the
information technology and startup sectors, has become a global innovation hub,
contributing greatly to a higher RoR in the technology sectors These
technological advancements have not only improved efficiency but also created
new markets and expanded access to customers,
which overall increases ROI for investors in both countries.
Conclusion
In conclusion, this
study underscores the critical role of cross-border investment in fostering
economic growth and enhancing global competitiveness for developing countries
like Indonesia and India. Through a comprehensive literature review, the
research highlights the significant reciprocal relationship between economic
growth and investment, with both countries demonstrating unique economic,
political, and social dynamics that influence investment returns. By focusing
on Rate of Return (RoR) and Return on Investment (RoI) as key indicators, the
study provides a nuanced understanding of investment performance in Indonesia
and India. The comparative analysis reveals that while both countries offer
substantial investment opportunities, the factors influencing RoR and RoI vary
due to their distinct environments. This research not only offers a comparative
picture of investment returns in both nations but also delves deeper into the
underlying factors affecting these returns. The insights gained from this study
are valuable for investors and policymakers, providing a foundation for
strategic decision-making and policy formulation aimed at optimizing investment
environments. Ultimately, the findings contribute to a broader comprehension of
the diverse and dynamic investment landscapes in Indonesia and India,
reinforcing the importance of tailored investment strategies to leverage their
economic potential effectively.
Bibliography
Agrawal, R. (2020). Review
of infrastructure development and its financing in India. Paradigm, 24(1),
109126.
Ain, N. N. (2020). Pengaruh
Investasi terhadap Pertumbuhan dan Pembangunan Ekonomi. Jurnal Al -Tsaman.
Ain, N. N. (2021). Pengaruh
Investasi Terhadap Pertumbuhan dan Pembangunan Ekonomi. Al-Tsaman: Jurnal
Ekonomi Dan Keuangan Islam, 3(1), 162169.
Anas, T., Hill, H., Narjoko,
D., & Putra, C. T. (2022). The Indonesian economy in turbulent times. Bulletin
of Indonesian Economic Studies, 58(3), 241271.
Anisah, S., & Al, E.
(2020). Perlindungan Hukum Usaha Mikro Kecil Menengah (Umkm) Sektor Perkebunan
Dari Dominasi Kepemilikan Modal Asing Di Indonesia. Deepublish, 1(1).
Ardon, O., Asa, S. L.,
Lloyd, M. C., Lujan, G., Parwani, A., Santa-Rosario, J. C., Van Meter, B.,
Samboy, J., Pirain, D., Blakely, S., & Hanna, M. G. (2024). Understanding
the financial aspects of digital pathology: A dynamic customizable return on
investment calculator for informed decision-making. Journal of Pathology
Informatics, 15. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpi.2024.100376
Avdasheva, S., & Orlova,
Y. (2020). Effects of long-term tariff regulation on investments under low
credibility of rules: Rate-of-return and price cap in Russian electricity
grids. Energy Policy, 138.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enpol.2020.111276
Bharadwaj, P., Nicola, L.,
Breau-Brunel, M., Sensini, F., Tanova-Yotova, N., Atanasov, P., Lobig, F.,
& Blankenburg, M. (2024). Unlocking the Value: Quantifying the Return on
Investment of Hospital Artificial Intelligence. Journal of the American
College of Radiology. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jacr.2024.02.034
Budianto, E. W. H., &
Dewi, N. D. T. (2023). Pemetaan Penelitian Rasio Total Asset Turnover (TATO)
pada Perbankan Syariah dan Konvensional: Studi Bibliometrik VOSviewer dan
Literature Review. Jurnal Akuntansi Dan Manajemen, 20(2).
https://doi.org/10.36406/jam.v20i2.975
Carvajal, M. J., &
Popovici, I. (2021). The rate of return to a pharmacy education investment in
the U.S. Research in Social and Administrative Pharmacy, 17(5),
904910. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sapharm.2020.07.022
Clare, G., Diprose, G., Lee,
L., Bremer, P., Skeaff, S., & Mirosa, M. (2023). Measuring the impact of
food rescue: A social return on investment analysis. Food Policy, 117.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodpol.2023.102454
Dong, X., Yang, R., Ye, Y.,
& Cui, L. (2023). Trade-off efficiency: Linking urban socioecological
quality with land use efficiency from return on investment perspective. Sustainable
Cities and Society, 99. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scs.2023.104968
Guna, R. A., Fauzan, F. H.
Al, & Kusumastuti, R. (2023a). PENGARUH ROI (RETURN ON INVESTMENT) DAN ROE
(RETURN ON EQUITY) TERHADAP HARGA SAHAM di CIMB NIAGA PERIODE 2020-2021. Jurnal
Ilmiah Manajemen, Bisnis Dan Kewirausahaan, 3(2).
https://doi.org/10.55606/jurimbik.v3i2.478
Guna, R. A., Fauzan, F. H.
Al, & Kusumastuti, R. (2023b). PENGARUH ROI (RETURN ON INVESTMENT) DAN ROE
(RETURN ON EQUITY) TERHADAP HARGA SAHAM di CIMB NIAGA PERIODE 2020-2021. Jurnal
Ilmiah Manajemen, Bisnis Dan Kewirausahaan, 3(2), 197205. https://doi.org/10.55606/jurimbik.v3i2.478
Hjerpe, E. E., Colavito, M.
M., Waltz, A. E. M., & Meador, A. S. (2024a). Return on investments in
restoration and fuel treatments in frequent-fire forests of the American west:
A meta-analysis. Ecological Economics, 223.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2024.108244
Hjerpe, E. E., Colavito, M.
M., Waltz, A. E. M., & Meador, A. S. (2024b). Return on investments in
restoration and fuel treatments in frequent-fire forests of the American west:
A meta-analysis. Ecological Economics, 223.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2024.108244
Kadyraliev, A., Supaeva, G.,
Bakas, B., Dzholdosheva, T., Dzholdoshev, N., Balova, S., Tyurina, Y., &
Krinichansky, K. (2022). Investments in transport infrastructure as a factor
of stimulation of economic development. Transportation Research Procedia,
63, 13591369.
Majid, M. (2020). Renewable
energy for sustainable development in India: current status, future prospects,
challenges, employment, and investment opportunities. Energy, Sustainability
and Society, 10(1), 136.
Nadzir, M., &
Setyaningrum Kenda, A. (2023). Investasi asing dan investasi dalam negeri:
Pengaruhnya pada pertumbuhan ekonomi di indonesia. Jurnal Ilmiah Mahasiswa
Akuntansi ) Universitas Pendidikan Ganesha, 14.
Putri, S. A., Oktavia, R.,
& Eka Putri, W. R. (2020). Pengaruh Kinerja Keuangan Terhadap Rate of
Return (Studi Empiris Pada Perusahaan Pertambangan Yang Terdaftar di BEI Tahun
2014-2018 ). Jurnal Akuntansi Dan Keuangan, 25(2).
https://doi.org/10.23960/jak.v25i2.136
Robby Nugraha, T. Y. (2023).
KERJASAMA PERDAGANGAN INDONESIA - INDIA DALAM MENINGKATKAN EKSPOR KOMODITAS
REMPAH. Jurnal Manajemen, Akuntansi, Ekonomi, 2(2).
https://doi.org/10.59066/jmae.v2i2.439
Saidi, S., Mani, V., Mefteh,
H., Shahbaz, M., & Akhtar, P. (2020). Dynamic linkages between transport,
logistics, foreign direct Investment, and economic growth: Empirical evidence
from developing countries. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and
Practice, 141, 277293.
Siti Anisah, S. H. (2020). Perlindungan
Hukum Usaha Mikro Kecil Menengah (UMKM) Sektor Perkebunan dari Dominasi
Kepemilikan Modal Asing di Indonesia.
Srivastava, A., &
Muharam, H. (2022). Value relevance of accounting information during IFRS
convergence period: comparative evidence between India and Indonesia. Accounting
Research Journal, 35(2), 276291.
Wang, C., Lim, M. K., Zhang,
X., Zhao, L., & Lee, P. T.-W. (2020). Railway and road infrastructure in
the Belt and Road Initiative countries: Estimating the impact of transport
infrastructure on economic growth. Transportation Research Part A: Policy
and Practice, 134, 288307.
|
Rika Yohana Sari, Batina Yulia Utami, Hadianto, Yahya (2024) |
|
First publication right: Advances in
Social Humanities Research |
|
This article is licensed under:
|
